CRA hits taxpayer with hefty ‘foreign property’ penalty

Article content material

As you start to organize your 2024 tax return within the days forward, it’s best to pay shut consideration to a seemingly innocuous query on web page 2 of the return. The query asks whether or not you owned or held “specified overseas property” the place the overall value quantity of all such property, at any time in 2024, was greater than $100,000. If the reply is sure, the return instructs you to finish Type T1135, International Earnings Verification Assertion.

Article content material

Article content material

Article content material

There are substantial penalties for failure to file this way, as one taxpayer not too long ago discovered in a tax case determined final month. However earlier than delving into the main points of this newest T1135 penalty case, let’s briefly assessment the overseas property reporting guidelines.

Specified overseas property contains apparent overseas property, resembling a Bahamian checking account or Bermudian offshore funding portfolio, in addition to valuable metals held exterior Canada. Additionally included are overseas shares, resembling Apple Inc., Microsoft Corp. or Meta Platforms Inc., debt of a non-resident issuer, or an curiosity in a non-resident belief held in a Canadian, non-registered brokerage account. Choices to buy specified overseas property are additionally included.

If you happen to maintain overseas securities in a Canadian brokerage account, take into account the residency of the issuer of the safety. If the issuer is a non-resident of Canada, then the securities rely as specified overseas property. Observe that it’s irrelevant whether or not the safety is listed on a Canadian or overseas inventory change, or if the safety is denominated in Canadian or overseas forex.

Article content material

Article content material

Some overseas property don’t have to be reported. For instance, overseas securities held inside Canadian pooled merchandise, resembling Canadian mutual funds, needn’t be reported; nevertheless, should you put money into a non-resident mutual fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF), then that’s overseas property. A overseas forex checking account held with a financial institution in Canada resembling a U.S. greenback chequing account isn’t thought of specified overseas property, nor are U.S. money balances sitting in your non-registered Canadian brokerage buying and selling account. Solely money in offshore accounts, as an example an Arizona chequing account, is reportable overseas property.

If you happen to personal a overseas trip dwelling, resembling a rental in Costa Rica, it’s excluded supplied it’s primarily on your private use. A rental property positioned exterior of Canada would, nevertheless, be included in property to be reported.

Lastly, property held in registered plans, resembling a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), registered retirement earnings fund (RRIF) or tax-free savings account (TFSA), in addition to overseas property used completely in carrying on an lively enterprise, needn’t be reported.

Article content material

In case you are required to file a T1135, it’s vital that you simply file on time or threat a late-filing penalty of $25 per day to a most of $2,500, plus arrears curiosity. If, nevertheless, you fail to file the T1135 “knowingly or underneath circumstances amounting to gross negligence,” the penalty jumps to $500 monthly for every month that the return is late, to a most of $12,000. After 24 months, the penalty turns into 5 per cent of the price of the overseas property, much less any penalties already assessed.

This newest T1135 case concerned a taxpayer who uncared for to file T1135s for the years 1998 via 2013, and was hit with gross negligence penalties and curiosity for every of these tax years.

The taxpayer had a bachelor of science in mining engineering and was an expert engineer. He labored in Canada from 1979 to 1982, after which labored in Libya as an engineering supervisor till 1994.

In April 1997, when the taxpayer was considering his return to Canada, he opened a Swiss checking account and funded it with the equal of $431,000 in Canadian {dollars} that he had earned in Libya. It was a numbered Swiss account and, for a price, the Swiss financial institution held all associated documentation. All enterprise transacted between the taxpayer and the Swiss financial institution was by phone. He opened the Swiss checking account to cover the funds from his spouse, with whom he was having marital difficulties. He was involved that he would quickly be divorced so he wished to maintain cash offshore to fund his potential post-divorce life.

Article content material

The taxpayer in the end returned to Canada and have become a Canadian resident for earnings tax functions. He didn’t report any of the earnings, features or losses for the Swiss checking account in his tax returns for any of the 1998 to 2013 taxation years, nor did he file T1135s for these years.

The CRA reassessed the taxpayer for these taxation years to incorporate in his earnings quantities in reference to the Swiss checking account, and imposed each gross negligence penalties, and penalties for the failure to file T1135 kinds.

For annually from 1998 to 2013, the taxpayer’s accountant ready his earnings tax return primarily based on the paperwork supplied by him. The taxpayer didn’t disclose the existence of the Swiss checking account to his accountant, nor did he present his accountant any documentation in relation to the account for these taxation years.

The taxpayer testified that he believed that since he had earned the cash used to fund the Swiss checking account whereas he was working in Libya, it was not taxable in Canada. He referred to provisions in two of Canada’s earnings tax treaties that present the complexity of the taxation of internationally earned earnings. He additionally argued that he had understood that the Swiss financial institution was taking good care of any tax related to that account. This was constant along with his expertise in Libya, the place his employer took care of all taxes.

Article content material

The decide didn’t purchase the taxpayer’s explanations, saying, “None of those causes are convincing.” Added the decide, “This isn’t a state of affairs the place it may very well be stated that the taxpayer was misled by their tax preparer. It was not a posh construction or an arcane level of tax legislation — the taxation of Canadian residents on their worldwide earnings is among the foundational guidelines of Canadian earnings tax legislation.”

Accordingly, the decide discovered that the taxpayer did not file a T1135 type for every of the 2007 to 2013 taxation years “knowingly or underneath circumstances amounting to gross negligence,” and that the CRA correctly assessed the gross negligence penalties for failure to file annually’s T1135.

Even for these of us with out Swiss financial institution accounts, this case serves as an vital reminder to fill out the T1135 yearly, even when it’s merely to report the U.S. securities in our Canadian brokerage account.

Jamie Golombek, FCPA, FCA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.

If you happen to favored this story, join extra within the FP Investor e-newsletter.

Bookmark our web site and assist our journalism: Don’t miss the enterprise information you must know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and join our newsletters here.

Article content material